Fake Sellers Target Holiday Shoppers as Marketplace Scams Surge Online

Every November, the holiday shopping season begins with a sense of excitement and ends, for some, in regret. As millions of consumers flood marketplaces like Amazon, Facebook, and eBay in search of last-minute gifts and doorbuster deals, an unseen network of scammers is doing the same targeting wallets instead of wish lists.

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) has issued repeated warnings that fake marketplace listings and delivery scams surge in the weeks before Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Fraudsters create polished storefronts, steal real product images, and mimic seller language so well that even seasoned online shoppers struggle to tell the difference.

This year, experts say, the risk is higher than ever. Inflation anxiety and tighter budgets are pushing shoppers to hunt for bargains often on unfamiliar sites and scammers know it.

The Perfect Storm: Inflation, Impulse, and Urgency

Spending Under Pressure

Holiday 2025 spending is expected to top $1 trillion, yet consumers remain financially stretched. Many are living paycheck-to-paycheck, chasing discounts wherever they appear. This behavior creates fertile ground for fraud.

A recent report on consumer vulnerability found that three in ten Americans roughly 77 million people have lost money to a scam in the past five years, often more than $500 per incident.

The report revealed sharp generational differences:

• Younger adults (Gen Z and millennials) are more often targeted on social platforms and apps.
• Older adults and baby boomers are more likely to fall victim to fake eCommerce or marketplace scams and lose more money when they do.

The Psychology of the Click

Scammers understand that speed is their greatest weapon. During the holidays, when limited-time deals dominate headlines, fraudsters mirror the pace and tone of legitimate shopping experiences. They build fake listings that feel urgent: “Only 3 left!” or “Sale ends in 30 minutes.” Once a buyer engages, they reply instantly matching the tempo consumers expect from genuine customer service.

According to the Block “Financial Scams and Consumer Trust” report, more than half of victims send money within 24 hours of first contact, and one in four within 30 minutes.

“Fraudsters don’t need to steal your identity if they can steal your attention,” said Kelly Harper, a financial crimes researcher. “They know that holiday urgency is worth more than any password.”

Anatomy of a Marketplace Scam

Stage	Fraudster Tactic	Consumer Trap
1. Listing Creation	Uses stolen product photos and fake reviews to mimic top sellers.	Shoppers trust the visual familiarity of legitimate listings.
2. Urgent Messaging	“Limited stock” or “Flash sale” language to trigger fast action.	Shoppers skip background checks or seller verification.
3. Payment Diversion	Requests off-platform payments via gift cards, direct transfer, or payment apps.	Buyers lose platform protection and refund rights.
4. Delivery Impersonation	Sends fake tracking links or texts impersonating delivery companies.	Victims click phishing links or share personal data.
5. Vanishing Act	Seller deletes profile and reappears under new alias.	No recourse or traceability for victims.

This method is alarmingly effective because it blends into legitimate workflows email confirmations, shipment updates, and customer support chats.

How Generational Differences Shape Ris

Demographic analysis shows that baby boomers and seniors suffer fake eCommerce scams at three times the rate of Gen Z. Younger shoppers tend to recognize red flags faster or use safer payment options like digital wallets.

Age Group	Common Scam Exposure	Average Loss
Gen Z (18–26)	Social media giveaways, influencer scams	$150–$300
Millennials (27–42)	App-based and peer-to-peer payment scams	$300–$600
Gen X (43–58)	Marketplace resale scams	$500–$800
Boomers & Seniors (59+)	Fake eCommerce and delivery scams	$800–$1,500

Older consumers’ shopping habits using desktop browsers, searching for “best deals,” and trusting brand lookalikes make them especially vulnerable during sales events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

The Financial Fallout: When Fraud Erodes Trust

The ripple effects of marketplace scams extend far beyond the transaction. PYMNTS Intelligence data shows that after being scammed:

• 32% of victims stop opening emails from unfamiliar senders.
• 30% stop answering texts or calls from unknown numbers.
• 25% avoid new or unfamiliar shopping sites altogether.

This erosion of confidence hits both retailers and banks. Among victims of financial scams:

• 42% consider switching banks afterward.
• 19% actually change providers.
• 23% never report the scam to their bank.

Reporting, however, matters. Of those who do alert their financial institution, 53% recover most or all of their funds, compared with only 12% of those who remain silent.

“Every unreported scam emboldens the next one,” said Ellen Boyd, a cybersecurity policy advisor. “Consumers need to treat scam reporting as part of digital hygiene like updating your passwords or checking your credit score.”

Why the Holiday Season Magnifies Risk

1. Deal Urgency: Limited-time offers and countdowns trigger impulsive decisions.
2. High Transaction Volume: Payment platforms are flooded, giving scammers cover.
3. Emotional Decision-Making: Gifting, stress, and time pressure lower vigilance.
4. Seasonal Impersonation: Scammers pose as delivery services, customer support, or brand representatives.
5. Digital Noise: Promotional emails and texts make phishing harder to detect.

The Institutional Response: Building Defenses

Financial institutions, marketplaces, and merchants are intensifying fraud prevention efforts. Banks and payment providers are rolling out faster anomaly detection systems that flag unusual transfers or multiple transactions in short bursts a hallmark of holiday fraud. Marketplaces are refining seller verification, employing machine learning to detect fake listings, duplicate photos, and suspicious shipping data.

Education campaigns are also critical. Many consumers still don’t know they can report scams to their banks or platforms. Simple awareness can prevent losses: more than half of victims who reported promptly recovered their money.

How Shoppers Can Protect Themselves

Action	Why It Matters
Buy only through verified marketplace payment systems.	Keeps purchase protection in place.
Avoid sellers asking for wire transfers or gift cards.	These payments are untraceable and irreversible.
Check seller histories and reviews carefully.	Fake accounts often lack long-term activity or verified purchases.
Ignore unsolicited “delivery” or “order issue” texts.	Scammers use fake shipment updates to steal credentials.
Report suspicious listings immediately.	Early reporting helps marketplaces remove fraudulent sellers quickly.

A Warning for the 2025 Shopping Season

Experts agree that 2025’s holiday rush will be both digitally dynamic and fraud-heavy. Scammers are evolving alongside platforms, leveraging AI tools to create more authentic listings and mimic real brand communication.

Financial analyst Victor Ruiz summarized the stakes bluntly:

“Fraud is scaling faster than consumer education. Unless institutions and shoppers adapt together, the scammers will always be one click ahead.”

For legitimate retailers, trust itself has become the new currency. Protecting it will define not just this holiday season, but the future of digital commerce.

Conclusion: The Cost of Convenience

The same forces that make online shopping fast and convenient instant transactions, 24/7 access, and automated communication also make it fertile ground for fraud. This holiday season, the real challenge isn’t just finding the best deal; it’s avoiding the fake one. As scammers exploit shoppers’ trust and urgency, vigilance becomes as important as value. For consumers and institutions alike, protecting digital trust may be the most important purchase of the season.

FAQs