Amazon Rufus vs. Walmart Sparky: The New AI Rivalry Driving Holiday Retail Spend

This holiday season, the biggest competition in retail isn’t on the store shelf it’s inside the shopping app. Amazon and Walmart, two of America’s largest retailers, are quietly rewriting the playbook for digital commerce with their AI-powered shopping assistants, Rufus and Sparky.

Both started as tools meant to make shopping easier. But in late 2025, they’ve become central to something far more strategic: turning conversation into commerce. Each platform now injects paid recommendations “sponsored prompts” directly into its AI dialogues. It’s a radical rethinking of the way retail media, advertising, and customer journeys intersect.

As consumers navigate an economy defined by mixed signals falling inflation but rising anxiety, strong spending but shrinking savings the question isn’t just what they’ll buy. It’s how they’ll decide.

AI Holiday Shopping Rivalry: Rufus vs. Sparky at a Glance

Feature / Area	Amazon Rufus	Walmart Sparky
Role	AI shopping assistant for Amazon shoppers	AI-powered shopping assistant for Walmart customers
Launched	2024	Pilot began 2025
New ad format	Sponsored prompts announced Nov. 18	Testing “Sponsored Prompt” ad format
Scale (2025)	250M+ customers used Rufus; users up 149%, interactions up 210%	Smaller scale but growing within Walmart’s digital channels
Impact on purchasing	Rufus users are 60% more likely to buy on that trip	Sparky drives discovery and value-driven recommendations
Revenue strategy	Tie AI to retail media and ad revenue	Turn AI from convenience tool into media and value engine
Shopper experience	Deep product graph, strong personalization	Strong value messaging, price-sensitive suggestions

The Economic Backdrop: Cautious Spending in a Tense Economy

Despite inflation cooling from its 2022 highs, the U.S. consumer remains cautious. Retail earnings for the fourth quarter of 2025 show a paradoxical shopper: still spending, but choosing more carefully.

The National Retail Federation (NRF) projects holiday spending to exceed $1 trillion, a 3.7% to 4.2% increase from last year. Yet, a “Paycheck-to-Paycheck” report from PYMNTS found that 26% of consumers struggled to pay their bills in September 2025 the highest in two years.

For retailers, the message is clear: value matters more than ever. Shoppers want deals, but they also crave convenience, faster delivery, and personalized experiences. That’s where AI fits in not just as a novelty, but as a strategic growth engine.

From Browsing to Conversational Commerce

In traditional eCommerce, consumers scroll through product grids, compare prices, and click “add to cart.” In the new world of agentic AI, that process looks very different.

AI shopping assistants like Rufus and Sparky let users ask questions in natural language “What’s a good air fryer under $100?” or “Find a waterproof jacket for Chicago winters.” The AI then interprets intent, searches the catalog, and recommends products complete with reviews, comparisons, and now, sponsored suggestions.

Platform	AI Assistant	Feature Launched	New Advertising Model	Key Metric
Amazon	Rufus	2024	Sponsored Prompts (Nov 2025)	250M users, +149% MAU growth
Walmart	Sparky	2025	Sponsored Prompt Pilot	Expanding ad inventory within AI chat

Amazon reported that customers using Rufus are 60% more likely to make a purchase during their shopping session a data point that underscores how deeply conversational commerce may reshape retail conversion models.

The Strategic Stakes: Turning AI Into Retail Media

For both Walmart and Amazon, these AI agents are more than digital helpers. They’re new advertising ecosystems. Walmart’s introduction of “Sponsored Prompt” ads marks its first move to treat AI as a revenue-generating media channel. Until now, Sparky functioned mainly as a service tool a conversational layer to make shopping smoother.

By embedding ads directly into the AI’s responses, Walmart joins Amazon in a new phase of retail competition where AI agents become both salespeople and ad platforms.

“Sponsored prompts are the new storefront window,” said one retail strategist familiar with Walmart’s AI plans. “They bring marketing and commerce together in a single sentence of conversation.”

Rethinking Retail Architecture for the AI Era

This transformation goes beyond advertising. It’s changing how the entire retail system operates. Data from the “Prompt Economy” framework an emerging analytical model in digital commerce shows that as AI agents become digital concierges, merchants must optimize not just for human shoppers, but for machine readers.

That means product descriptions, inventory data, and brand attributes must be structured so AI systems can interpret and recommend them seamlessly. Retailers are now designing not only for search algorithms, but for AI dialogue flows.

Traditional Commerce Model	AI-Led Commerce Model
Search-based discovery	Intent-based conversation
Keyword optimization	Context optimization
Display ads & banners	Conversational prompts
Click-through rates	Engagement per dialogue
Manual comparison	AI-assisted curation

This reconfiguration affects everything from marketing strategy to supply chain logistics. Retailers that can align product data with AI logic ensuring that availability, pricing, and relevance match the customer’s real-time intent will lead the next phase of digital retail.

What It Means for Brands and Marketers?

For brands, this AI shift could upend how marketing budgets are spent. Traditional pay-per-click (PPC) and search engine optimization (SEO) strategies may lose relevance as consumers move away from search bars and toward conversational interfaces.

Instead, brands may invest in prompt placements short, context-aware messages surfaced inside AI assistants. Imagine a consumer asking, “What’s a good vitamin C serum?” and Sparky replying with both organic recommendations and a sponsored prompt for a featured skincare brand.

This new medium demands a rethinking of brand presence: not at the moment of visibility, but at the moment of relevance. Marketing analyst Jenna Torres explained, “We’ve optimized for visibility for 20 years. Now, we’re optimizing for dialogue. The ad you buy might not be a banner or a keyword it’s a sentence in a conversation.”

The Consumer Experience: Seamless, Personal, and Potentially Biased

AI-driven shopping assistants promise faster, more personal experiences but they also raise new concerns. If branded content is baked into conversational recommendations, how will consumers know where personalization ends and advertising begins? The blurring of that line could invite regulatory scrutiny or spark new demands for transparency in AI advertising.

Privacy is another flashpoint. As AI agents collect granular data on preferences, tone, and spending habits, companies must ensure that personalization doesn’t veer into intrusion. Still, for many shoppers, the tradeoff is worth it. The appeal of one-tap convenience and tailored advice may outweigh the opacity of who’s sponsoring what.

The Bigger Picture: AI as the New Retail Operating System

Beyond holiday promotions, the rise of Rufus and Sparky signals a long-term redefinition of retail itself. As AI becomes the interface between consumer intent and corporate supply chains, retailers will rely less on search traffic and more on machine-mediated discovery. Product recommendations will be generated not from keyword lists but from predictive, conversational insights about user intent, budget, and behavior. In short, the future of retail may look less like a search engine and more like a dialogue.

Conclusion: The Conversation Becomes the Marketplace

The 2025 holiday season may be remembered as the year retail became truly conversational. What started as convenience tools Sparky for Walmart, Rufus for Amazon has evolved into a battle for control over how consumers make choices in real time.

The shift from clicks to conversations isn’t just a technology story; it’s a cultural one. Shopping, once defined by browsing aisles or scrolling pages, is now defined by dialogue and the winner of that dialogue could define the next decade of commerce. In an economy where consumers are both cautious and connected, AI may prove to be retail’s most human interface yet.

FAQs